Russo sets out to relate the grotesque body to spatial and temporal dimensions of modern spectacle 6 and to explore the possibilities of the grotesque for a feminism she characterizes as too concerned with appearing mainstream 12. The essential principle of grotesque realism is degradation, the lowering of all that is abstract, spiritual, noble, and ideal to the material level. By employing subject matter and a visual style grounded in the grotesque. Female grotesques carnival and theory p r e t ext there is a phrase that still resonates from childhood.
She suggests that the carnivalesque destabilizes binary categories and presents momentary expressions of. Gender and negativity in frankenstein and the handmaids tale authors. The grotesque body is a concept, or literary trope, put forward by russian literary critic mikhail bakhtin in his study of francois rabelais work. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. Grotesque on the loose mary russo discusses female grotesque in female grotesques. Carnival and theory, mary russo 21 the empire strikes back. Pdf the grotesque female body, the gothic household and. The consumption, production and regulation of alcohol in the. Alcohol consumption in 21stcentury britain is of significant interest to government, media and academics. The politics of masculinity in the work of arthur miller and tennessee williams. Bakhtin never alluded directly to feminism, nevertheless his theories of dialogism. The second is to consider the case mary russo makes in the female grotesque 1994 for foregrounding the vulgar and unaesthetic in the cause of women. Theory of the grotesque is highly interested in bodily fluids particularly fluids. View bakhtin carnival and the grotesque body research papers on academia.
Stanford libraries official online search tool for books, media, journals, databases, government documents and more. Misogyny and the carnivalesque in wyndham lewiss the. Female body feminist theory shoot gallery double displacement russian scholar. Carnival and theory, and articulates the body as the site of female contamination and resistance. Concluding this work, suggestions are provided for future applications of feminist theory of. Bakhtin carnival and the grotesque body research papers. Some have referred to a new culture of intoxication or calculated hedonism, fostered b. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext.
Rather, humor is rebellious, it is a strategy that can be used to bring attention to significant ideas, to promote change, and to alter powerstructures. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves. Every day, in disparate venues, in response to sundry occasions, in front of precise audiences even if an audience of one, people assemble, if only temporarily, a life to which they assign narrative coherence and meaning and through which they position themselves in historically specific identities. Communists, cowboys, and queers david savran published by university of minnesota press savran, david. Stage representations of gender and sexuality lit8429 instructor. The moving wall represents the time period between the last issue available in jstor and the most recently published issue of a journal. This wonderful book does nothing less than to create the next stage of feminist thought. Let us also remember the carnival image of world catastrophe in the prophetic puzzle, streams of water which fills all were. See, for instance, elin diamonds mimesis, mimicry, and the true real.
It is a harsh, matronizing phrase, directed towards the behavior of other women. The masks and voices of carnival resist, exaggerate, and destabilize. The essays in this collection represent very recent developments in feminist research and writing in the areas of history, scientific discourse, literary criticism, and cultural theory. We use cookies to make interactions with our website easy and meaningful, to better understand the use of our services, and to tailor advertising. Many feminists in recent years have grappled with the question of humour and how it is often the site of much contestation when it comes to women using it as a tool of transgression.
Frederik byrn kohlert department of english, university of montreal, canada correspondence frederik. More specifically, this essay utilizes the theories as posited by mary russo in female grotesques. Let us also remember the carnival image of world catastrophe in the prophetic puzzle, streams of water which fills all were there then, and the world a fire was cheerful fire hearth. In eagletons formulation, the carnival can be seen as conveying precisely those features that concern winlow and hall. A posttranssexual manifesto, sandy stone 22 a provoking agent. Further aggravation has come from the application of bakhtins theory of carnival, especially in its posthumous form as a political allegory portraying the clash of high and low cultures. Stage representations of gender and sexuality lit8.
She the other woman is making a spectacle out of herself. Many feminists in recent years have grappled with the question of humour and how it is often the site of much contestation when it comes to women using it. The pornography and performance art of annie sprinkle, linda williams. These ideas connect to theories of resistance and subversion as articulated by judith butler. Mikhail bakhtins theory of grotesque and feminist theory eg. Its useful as a resource too since the bibliography at the back is extensive. Female body feminist theory shoot gallery double displacement russian scholar these keywords were added by machine and not by the authors.
Ben jonson has often been accused of needless erudition and of a morose refusal to join in the festive spirit. The simple answer, like most everything that is ideological, is yes. There is a phrase that still resonates from childhood. The mothers voicenot my own mothers, perhaps, but the voice of an aunt, an older sister, or the mother of a friend. Fat lady in the theatre, fat woman in car, and mother of 9 children are some of the roles attributed to uma devi khatri, aka tun tun, in her wikipedia filmography. Smother tongue feminism, academic discourse, translation. This chapter charts a possible re sponse to mary russos essay female grotesques. Tun tun, regularly typecast and often appearing for a few seconds without any narrative consequence, was a household name, yet her star persona has yet to garner much attention. Sometimes the grotesque in literature has been explored in terms of social and cultural formations such as the carnivalesque in francois rabelais and mikhail bakhtin. Pdf the article will show that in nights at the circus, carters use of the themes of food. Risk, excess and modernity 1994, defines both beautifully. Carnival in bakhtins account is a kind of detranscendence of the world, the replacement of the fixed order of language held in place by a mastersignifier or trunk with a free slippage of signifiers in a space of immanence. In a major addition to the literature of art, cultural criticism and feminist studies, mary russo reexamines the grotesque in the light of gender, exploring the works of angela carter david cronenberg bahktin kristeva freud zizek. In this paper, i draw on gilles deleuze and felix guattaris concept of faciality to unpack the ways in which umiumare and leongs mobilization of the many monstrous faces of the other is, in fact, a complex theatrical strategy designed.
Terry castle has written on the relationship between metamorphosis, literary writings and masquerade. The grotesque is one of the most obvious forms art may take to pierce the. Topics in feminist philosophy in philosophy of gender, race, and sexuality. I will consider how madonna embodies ideals of the carnivalesque, by incorporating theories of the grotesque and the unruly. Elizabeth sakellaridou fall semester 20072008 course outline week 1 810. Carnival and the ory and to her interrogation concerning the relation of the grotesque, namely the bakhtinian strand, with the politics of feminism, or, to use her terms, how carnival as historical performance relates to carnival as semiotic performance. Concluding this work, suggestions are provided for future applications of feminist theory of the dressed body to textiles and clothing scholarship.
It occurs on the border between art and life, and is a kind of life shaped according to a pattern of play and marked by displays of excess and. Contents part 4 body on stage the opposite sex is neither. How was bahktins theory of the carnival represented in the. In its multivalent oppositional play, carnival refuses to surrender the critical and cultural tools of the dominant class, and in this sense, carnival can be seen, above all, as a site of insurgency, and not merely withdrawal. Macmillan, 1988, first published by indiana university press, 1986. Carnivalesque the female grotesque theory of carnival theory of carnival a carnival is a moment when everything is permitted. Risk, excess and modernityespecially her chapter female grotesques. Whereas female exposure is associated with inadvertency and loss of boundaries. Drawing on psychoanalytic theory, feminist theory, semi otics and aesthetics. In rare instances, a publisher has elected to have a zero moving wall, so their current issues are available. The chief difficulty encountered in seeking to define the grotesque in its relation to media isas can be attested to by every theoretician who has sought to do so since the sixteenth century conception of the term in its modern sensethat the grotesque is not an expression of norms, but rather what results from the transgression of them. For bakhtin, the grotesque is intrinsically associated with carnival. Center for twentieth century studies, university of wisconsinmilwaukee feminist approaches to philosophy in philosophy of gender, race, and sexuality.
The ethics of theory making in polyvocal criticism. Gender, humour and transgression in canadian womens theatre. Throughout the discussion, feminist theories of the dressed body are compared and situated with respect to broader feminist ideologies and assumptions. Kate bornstein 19 one is not born a woman moniquewittig 309 20 female grotesques. Emancipating the female sex the struggle for womens rights in brazil, 18501940. The grotesque the exagggerated, the deformed, the monstrous has been a wellconsidered subject for students of comparative literature and art. Drawn from a broad range of disciplines, writing on the body explores the tensions between womens lived bodily experiences and the cultural meanings inscribed on the female body.
496 1174 114 760 1341 394 665 1214 1156 1282 709 67 148 736 883 1307 898 1429 1303 1429 1233 244 1074 77 228 462 1002 923 287 307 821 1097 785 148